The Mythology of Theology


As the grave grows nearer, my theology is growing strangely simple, and it begins and ends with Christ as the only Savior of the lost.
~Henry Benjamin Whipple (1822-1901)

I have many more things to say to you, but you cannot bear them now.  But when He, the Spirit of truth, comes, He will guide you into all the truth; for He will not speak on His own initiative, but whatever He hears, He will speak; and He will disclose to you what is to come.  He will glorify Me, for He will take of Mine and will disclose it to you.
~ Jesus, King of The Universe, in John 16


The most blessed result of prayer would be to rise thinking, But I never knew before. I never dreamed… I suppose it was at such a moment that Thomas Aquinas said of all his own theology, “It reminds me of straw.”
~C. S. Lewis (1898-1963)

This entry, beloved, is not a rant against some theological construct.  Nah, i’m no good at stuff like that.  Plus, there is just no Life in knocking down one straw man, just so another one can be setup to be pummeled.


Rather, dear reader, it is a plea.

Listen to Him.  

He speaks into our lives in mighty ways.  He shows us the paths of life.  He makes them straight.  He prepares our works that we might walk in them.  He transforms us by the renewing of our minds. Read it. All of this is in His Word.

This is a plea to quit trying to figure Him out, and simply trust Him.  And then, in learning to trust – begin to obey.  For, it has been truly said that orthodoxy (good theology) without obedience simply does not yield renewal.

Oh yeah, read the Bible (as in a lot; as in a bunch – many times a day).  But when we read it, might we begin to sense that it is Him talking to us and telling us The Truth.  It is not a textbook about Him, filled with truth.  

It is not some text to be put to some test of textual criticism.  Oh by the way, one can do that, and the Book itself will stand up quite well.  The Book itself would be convicted of being true in any court on the planet.  But, that is not the point.  It is not about the Book.  It is about Him.

Our theology must be something that flows from our knowledge of Him, through our relationship with Him.  Theology can not work to get us closer to Him.  He is the One who brings us closer to Himself.

All human theology is but mythology.  It contains (often) great gobs of great truth, but it almost always draws us into two traps.  (1) As we begin to think we actually have a relatively full grasp of Him, the truths we do know tempt us to think we are actually developing some form of righteousness of our own.  We begin to think that – because we know something about Him – He will be more likely to accept us.  (2) Then, the insidious downside of theology is that the evil one will insert seeds of thought along the lines of: “Did He really say?…”, and suddenly our models begin to fall short of the true grandeur of Him (The actual Way, Truth, and Life).  Or worse, our theology drives us off the narrow path altogether.

Get this friends.  Good doctrine is vital.  But, this doctrine cannot be truly learned from a book.  It is His Spirit that teaches us.  He will use His Word.  He might use a book, or a preacher, or a professor, or a song, or a hymn, or a sunrise to teach us – but it is Him doing the illumination of our souls.

Him.

The danger of an unspiritual theology may take either of two forms. The first occurs when theology is afraid to yield itself unreservedly to the leading of the Spirit and defers to other authorities, when it “rotates in circles of historicism, rationalism, moralism, romanticism, dogmatism or intellectualism.” The other occurs when theology assumes that it possesses the Spirit ex officio, as it were. “The presence and action of the Spirit are the grace of God who is always free.” The Spirit cannot be domesticated in the Church or any of its offices. “Only when he is sighed, cried, and prayed for, does he become present and newly active. Veni Creator Spiritus! Come, O come, thou Spirit of Life.” 
~George S. Hendry

2 Comments

  1. wisdomquest March 3, 2012
  2. Makala Doulos March 3, 2012